The impact of Thalia “wins” within the sense that the earth at all times enters touched, however has nothing to do with the order between the alternative results.
Every little thing enters the default battlefield, together with land (CR 110.5b. The alternative results on each Fort Embereth and Thalia, Heretic Cathar modify that by making the land enter touched. Fort Embereth’s skill does it conditionally, and Thalia’s does it unconditionally.
The critic that should see right here is that when the situation for the impact of Fort Embereth isn’t glad, the impact does nothing. It doesn’t make the earth with out exploiting. Fort Embereth’s skill might be divided into two components: the impact is “this land comes into blow” and the situation is “until you management a mountain.” If you don’t management a mountain, the impact applies and makes the earth enter. If it controls a mountain, the impact doesn’t apply, so it doesn’t make the land enter exploited. However neither does the earth between non -exploit.
So, assuming that we apply the Fort Embereth impact in second place, that is how the alternative results are utilized if the participant doesn’t management a mountain:
- The earth enters blow (Thalia)
- The earth enters blow (Fort Embereth)
End result: The land entered touched.
And that is how the alternative results apply if the participant controls a mountain:
- The earth enters blow (Thalia)
- This impact does nothing (Fort Embereth)
End result: The land entered touched.
To finish, the alternative results might be utilized in any order, and the participant who controls Fort Embereth chooses order. This can be a consequence of Rule 616.1:
If two or extra alternative results and/or prevention attempt to modify the best way an occasion impacts an object or participant, the controller of the affected object (or its proprietor if it doesn’t have a controller) or the affected participant chooses one to use, following the steps listed under. If two or extra gamers need to make these selections on the identical time, the elections are taken in APNAP order (see rule 101.4).
