He intention Marina’s capability is a room, not a door. With returning the favor, your opponent can select a distinct room by its second ability, however it’s at all times you who chooses the door to dam/unlock.
They mentioned that the power factors to a room door, the place every door is a separate entity of dimension
That isn’t right. Returning the favor requires a objective. Solely objects and gamers will be goal.
115.1. Some spells and abilities require their controller to decide on a number of targets for them. The targets are objects and/or gamers that may have an effect on spell or ability. These targets are declared as a part of the method of placing the spell or the ability within the pile. The targets can’t be modified, besides for one more spell or ability that explicitly says that it may well do it.
109.1. An object is a capability within the battery, a letter, a duplicate of a card, a token, a spell, a everlasting emblem or an emblem.
A room is an object. It has two halves since it’s a divided card, however you can’t intention These halves individually; The halves should not objects in themselves. Solely the complete everlasting room that accommodates them is an object. Even when the doorways had been objects, Marina’s capability remains to be going to the rooms; His capability would explicitly say that he can level to the doorways.
The one choice you carry out when activating the marine capability is which room to intention at. That can also be the one choice that your opponent can change by the second approach of return.
- Launch spells
601.2C The participant proclaims his selection of an acceptable object or participant for every goal required by the spell. (..) (The method is similar for abilities)
As well as, within the second approach, your opponent has to decide on a completely different room, if potential.
115.7a if an impact permits a participant to “change the target (s)” of a spell or ability, every goal can solely be modified to a different authorized goal. If one goal can’t be modified to a different authorized goal, the unique goal doesn’t change, even when the unique goal is in itself by then. If all targets don’t change to different authorized targets, none of them modifications.
When the capability is resolved, you as a capability controller select which door is blocked/unlock. That’s merely a part of the ability directions set. Your buddy is correct that the door you select will change your locking standing.
Your opponent might additionally select the primary half to return the favor, thus copying your capability. That might let your copy be affected, and the copy of your opponent can be resolved first. In case your opponent unlocks the door you wished to unlock anyway, you do not have to decide on the identical door. You’ll be able to select the opposite door, and your favourite door would stay unlocked. Once more, you make that call simply as your capability decisionWith full data of what occurred earlier than.
